Strategies to Combat Toxic, Villainous Workplace Behaviors

There is no great film or story without a great villain or conflict. But when the drama and villainous behavior seep into the workplace, your organization culture suffers. Absenteeism due to illness will increase; productivity will decrease; top talent will leave. And people will, unfortunately, loathe coming to work.

In a month of monsters and villains, we want to share the top toxic behaviors of coworkers and/or managers and how to combat them.

Poor Communication a la Romeo and Juliet:

Spoiler alert: Romeo and Juliet kill themselves because Romeo did not get the memo from Friar Lawrence. (Sure, more backstory there, but it comes down to this missed message and a very over-the-top reaction!)

If many of our favorite characters would just communicate with one another, we wouldn’t have the wealth of literature or movies we do today. Nevertheless, poor communication at work is simply maddening. When information is held, is unclear, or inconsistently shared, workplace culture suffers. Don’t assume employees and staff have gotten the memo!

Strategies and actions to combat miscommunication at work (and avoid the drama!)

Encourage Open and Transparent Communication

Foster a culture of openness: Encourage employees and leaders to share information freely, ask questions, and provide feedback without fear of judgment or retaliation.

Regular updates: Hold team meetings, newsletters, or internal platforms where important company updates are shared. Transparency reduces misunderstandings and keeps everyone informed.
Anonymous feedback options:Allow for anonymous suggestions or concerns to be shared. Start with an engagement survey. Use an online suggestion box. Promote honest communication without fear of repercussions.

Implement Active Listening

Train leaders and staff: Teach employees to listen actively, meaning they focus on understanding the speaker's message without interrupting or jumping to conclusions.

Paraphrase and confirm understanding: When someone speaks, confirm what they’ve said by summarizing or asking follow-up questions. This ensures clarity and demonstrates respect for their input.

Encourage two-way dialogue: Make sure communication isn’t one-sided. Leaders should actively seek input from their teams rather than only issuing directives.

Leverage Technology and Tools

Use collaboration tools: Platforms like Slack, Microsoft Teams, or project management systems can streamline communication, making it easier to track conversations and collaborate.

Video conferencing and face-to-face meetings: While technology is helpful, face-to-face communication (even via video) can resolve misunderstandings and build stronger relationships compared to emails or texts.

Accessible documentation: Create and maintain easily accessible resources like FAQs, guides, or shared folders so employees can find answers and information quickly.

Provide Regular Training and Support

Workshops on communication skills: Invest in training sessions that cover effective communication, conflict resolution, and emotional intelligence to help employees and managers communicate better.

Conflict resolution protocols: Establish clear guidelines on how to handle conflicts, emphasizing communication over confrontation.

Recognition of good communication: Highlight and reward individuals or teams who practice strong communication. This promotes a culture where effective communication is valued.

The Lego Movie’s Lord Business and his Team of Micro-Manager Robots – Micromanagement at its Finest

Simply put, micromanagement can be soul-crushing. Though The Lego Movie made it funny and oh-so-close-to-home (work) for many, micromanagement stifles creativity, pummels autonomy, and will drive your talent out. Micromanagement erodes trust and destroys morale.

Train your leaders to step back and let people do their jobs!

Strategies and Actions to Combat the Micromanager:

Set Clear Expectations

Define roles, goals, and deadlines upfront, ensuring everyone knows their responsibilities. This reduces the need for constant oversight as employees understand what’s expected.

Foster Trust and Autonomy

Encourage employees to make decisions within their roles and provide room for creativity. This builds confidence and accountability.

Implement Regular Check-Ins

Schedule structured progress meetings instead of daily oversight, allowing employees to report on their own time. This balances accountability with independence, limiting unnecessary control (and meetings)

Track and Measure Outcomes, Not Processes

Shift focus to tracking employee performance through results and milestones rather than day-to-day activities. This reduces the need for micromanagers to control every step. It encourages trust in team members' abilities.

Everybody Loves to Hate a Bully like Regina George (Mean Girls), Johnny Lawrence (The Karate Kid), and Chris Hargensen (Carrie)

These bullies are intricate studies of cruelty. Though we learn to love some, like Professor Snape in Harry Potter and even Johnny Lawrence just a teensy bit (the real bully is his coach), we simply want to see the others get what’s coming to them. Bullying behavior is often dismissed with justifications like they’re star performers or are under pressure. According to an HBR study, this mythology doesn’t hold up. Bullies tend to be mediocre. And, unfortunately, bullying at work continues to be a huge problem.

Identify bullying behavior at work:

Constant Criticism:

Receiving frequent, unfounded negative feedback or being publicly humiliated.

Exclusion:
Being deliberately isolated from meetings, events, or work-related activities.

Unreasonable Workload:
Being assigned excessive or demeaning tasks compared to others.

Rumors:
Coworkers or supervisors spreading false information to undermine someone's reputation.

Intimidation:
Using threats, aggressive language, or body language to control or scare.

Sabotage:
Deliberately undermining someone's work by withholding information or resources.

Inconsistent Application of Rules:
Being singled out for discipline or punishment without reasonable cause.

How to deal with bullying and harassment at work:

Prevention is Key:

Often, organization policies about bullying and harassment are reactive. But organizations can prevent bullying:

Soft skills training – active listening, assertive communication
Have a manual with clear roles and behavior expectations
Transparency – equitable and legitimate ways for employees to advance in the organization and earn rewards
Well-designed recruitment mechanisms
Prevent resource scarcity and try to decrease workplace stress. This can lead to negative behaviors.
360 evaluations and survey feedback (anonymous) can help identify downward bullying.

When bullying and/or harassment occurs, it’s important to follow these steps:

Document Incidents:

Keep a detailed record of bullying behavior, including dates, times, and witnesses. If you don’t write it down, it didn’t happen.

Report to HR or Management:

File a formal complaint, presenting your documentation of the bullying.

Confront the Bully:

If safe, assertively and calmly address the behavior with the bully directly.

Seek Support:

Talk to a trusted colleague, mentor, or counselor to manage stress and gain support.

Know Company Policies:

Familiarize yourself with your company's anti-bullying or harassment policies.

Escalate if Necessary:
If internal procedures fail, consider external legal advice or contacting regulatory bodies.

In films and stories, we can often identify the villains. At work, it might be a little more difficult. Instead of focusing on the person at work, we recommend that you focus on the behavior. Good people sometimes behave badly. When you identify the toxic behavior, then you can figure out how to best combat it.

Most of these issues can take time. They won’t resolve themselves in a final battle scene. Humans are complex. Behavior is complex. Working to resolve these problems will not only improve your leadership skills but also your workplace. Considering we spend 1/3 of our lives at work, it’s worth the time and investment.

Villainous Workplace Behaviors

How to Identify Toxic Behaviors and Combat Them

Poor Communication a la Romeo and Juliet:

Strategies and actions to combat miscommunication at work (and avoid the drama!)

Encourage Open and Transparent Communication

Implement Active Listening

Leverage Technology and Tools

Provide Regular Training and Support

The Lego Movie’s Lord Business and his Team of Micro-Manager Robots – Micromanagement at its Finest

Strategies and Actions to Combat the Micromanager:

Set Clear Expectations

Foster Trust and Autonomy

Implement Regular Check-Ins

Track and Measure Outcomes, Not Processes

Everybody Loves to Hate a Bully like Regina George (Mean Girls), Johnny Lawrence (The Karate Kid), and Chris Hargensen (Carrie)

Identify bullying behavior at work:

Constant Criticism:

Exclusion:

Unreasonable Workload:

Rumors:

Intimidation:

Sabotage:

Inconsistent Application of Rules:

How to deal with bullying and harassment at work:

Prevention is Key:

When bullying and/or harassment occurs, it’s important to follow these steps:

Document Incidents:

Report to HR or Management:

Confront the Bully:

Seek Support:

Know Company Policies:

Escalate if Necessary:

About

Follow

Contact

Subscribe

Quick links

Articles & research